The Portland Thorns’ push toward the 2026 NWSL playoffs just became considerably more difficult.
Portland announced Tuesday that midfielder Olivia Moultrie has been placed on the Season-Ending Injury list after suffering an ACL injury to her right knee during training. At just 20 years old, Moultrie had become one of the most important pieces of the Thorns’ attack, recording five goals and five assists in 16 appearances, including 15 starts.
Those numbers tell a pretty good story by themselves. Moultrie was directly involved in 10 Portland goals this season, but her value went beyond the final pass or shot. She gave the Thorns another player capable of receiving the ball in dangerous areas, combining with the forwards and turning a fairly ordinary possession into an attacking opportunity.
Portland now has to figure out how to replace all of that with 11 regular-season games remaining. The Thorns enter Saturday’s home match against Orlando at 9-4-6 with 31 points, sitting fifth in the NWSL after 19 games. The league expanded its regular season to 30 games this year, so there is still plenty of soccer left for head coach Robert Vilahamn to find an answer.
The Thorns Shouldn’t Try To Find Another Moultrie
The easiest reaction to an injury like this is to look at the bench and ask who replaces Moultrie. That probably isn’t the right question.
Portland doesn’t have another player who can simply step into her exact role and reproduce five goals, five assists and everything she contributes between the two penalty areas. Instead, Vilahamn needs to divide those responsibilities among several players. Jessie Fleming can take on more of the work progressing the ball through midfield, while Nina Nijstad, Cassandra Bogere and Shae Harvey give Portland different options alongside her. Deyna Castellanos can also play a larger role in creating chances closer to goal.
We already saw some of that against Boston Legacy FC last weekend. With Moultrie out of the lineup, Portland started Fleming and Nijstad together in midfield and had Castellanos, Pietra Tordin and Marie Müller operating behind Sophia Wilson in a 4-2-3-1. The result was four first-half goals and a 4-3 road victory.
That’s encouraging because Portland didn’t need one player to suddenly become Moultrie. Different players assumed pieces of the job, and the attack kept functioning.
Pietra Tordin Becomes Even More Important
If Portland is going to absorb this loss, Tordin may be the biggest reason why.
The 21-year-old has developed into one of the league’s most productive attacking players. Her hat trick against Boston gave her seven goals this season, and her eight assists leave her with a league-leading 15 goal contributions. She also became the youngest player in Thorns history to record an NWSL hat trick.
Before Moultrie’s injury, Portland could split a significant amount of its creative work between the two of them. Earlier this summer, they were tied for the team lead with 10 goal contributions apiece. Moultrie’s season ends at that number, while Tordin has continued climbing.
That doesn’t necessarily mean Tordin needs to shoot more or suddenly become Portland’s entire offense. It means the Thorns should look for more ways to get her on the ball in dangerous positions and allow her to create for the players around her.
With Moultrie unavailable, Tordin’s ability to both score and create becomes enormously valuable.
Sophia Wilson Has To Keep Doing Sophia Wilson Things
Portland also has the benefit of still possessing one of the best finishers in the league.
Sophia Wilson scored her ninth goal of the season against Boston and entered this weekend fourth in the NWSL Golden Boot race. The combination of Wilson and Tordin gives Portland two legitimate difference-makers at the top of the formation, which is a pretty nice place to start when trying to survive the loss of an attacking midfielder.
The attacking depth is also improving at exactly the right time. Morgan Weaver was removed from the Season-Ending Injury list in July and returned to the field against Boston, while Portland announced Friday that Caiya Hanks has also been cleared and is available for selection against Orlando. Reilyn Turner remains another established attacking option for Vilahamn.
That depth matters because Portland shouldn’t ask Wilson and Tordin to carry the entire attack for the next three months. There are enough forwards on this roster for Vilahamn to rotate players, alter formations and find matchups that work.
The Bigger Problem May Be Controlling Games
The Boston victory was encouraging, but it also showed why losing Moultrie could eventually hurt Portland in ways that aren’t immediately obvious.
The Thorns scored four goals and produced 14 shots, but Boston held 60% of the possession and scored three times. Portland jumped ahead 3-0 inside the opening nine minutes and led 4-2 at halftime, but the second half became much tighter and Boston eventually pulled within a goal in the 82nd minute.
One game doesn’t establish a trend, especially when Portland spent much of it protecting a substantial lead. Still, it highlights the balancing act Vilahamn faces.
The Thorns have enough speed and attacking talent to become a devastating transition team. Tordin, Wilson and the rest of Portland’s forwards can punish teams when space opens up. But relying too heavily on transition soccer could become dangerous against the NWSL’s best teams, especially in the postseason when opponents are more willing to slow games down and make Portland create against an organized defense.
That’s where Fleming’s role becomes particularly important. Portland doesn’t just need to replace Moultrie’s goals. It needs players who can help dictate possession, connect the midfield to the forwards and prevent matches from turning into end-to-end chaos every week.
A 4-3 win is fun. Having to win 4-3 every week is considerably less fun.
Portland Still Has Time To Figure This Out
The timing of Moultrie’s injury obviously hurts. Portland is well into the second half of the season and trying to establish itself among the league’s contenders.
Still, this isn’t a roster without alternatives. Tordin leads the league in goal contributions, Wilson has nine goals, Fleming gives Portland experience in the center of the field, and Weaver and Hanks are returning to an attack that already co-led the NWSL with 32 goals following the Boston victory.
The Thorns also have enough games remaining to experiment. Vilahamn can try different midfield combinations, change where Tordin receives the ball and determine how much responsibility Castellanos, Nijstad, Bogere and others can handle. What works against Orlando might look different from what Portland needs against Gotham, Washington or another contender later in the season.
That is probably the key to surviving this injury. Portland shouldn’t spend the rest of the season searching for “the Olivia Moultrie replacement.” There isn’t one.
Instead, the Thorns need Fleming to take on a little more responsibility in midfield. They need Tordin to continue creating. They need Wilson to keep finishing. They need their returning forwards to add depth, and they need Vilahamn to find a midfield combination capable of keeping games under control.
Losing Moultrie unquestionably lowers Portland’s margin for error. A player with 10 goal contributions doesn’t disappear from a lineup without consequences.
But it doesn’t have to end the Thorns’ season, either. Portland still has enough attacking talent to be dangerous, and the 4-3 win in Boston offered an early glimpse of what this team can look like without Moultrie.
Now comes the harder part: proving they can make it work for the rest of the season.
Be the first to comment