In the 129th edition of Oregon’s storied in-state rivalry—once known as the Civil War but now feeling more like a mercy rule—the Oregon State Beavers were thoroughly dismantled by the No. 6 Ducks, 41-7, at Autzen Stadium. What started as a flicker of competitiveness, with the Beavers tying the game at 7-7 late in the first quarter, devolved into a rout that saw Oregon outgain OSU 585-147. The Beavers managed just 43 yards after halftime, were held to eight first downs, and watched as Ducks quarterback Dante Moore threw for 305 yards and four touchdowns.
Now 0-4 for the first time since 2011, Oregon State faces a season teetering on the brink. Coach Trent Bray called it a “tale of two halves,” praising his team’s early resolve but lamenting the regression to familiar mistakes. But this loss wasn’t just about one game; it amplified deeper fissures in a program navigating conference realignment, roster turnover, and a rebuild in the remnants of the Pac-12. As the Beavers prepare for Houston on Friday—a game that could either spark a turnaround or deepen the despair—here are the major questions looming over Reser Stadium.
1. Can the Offense Find Any Identity Before It’s Too Late?
Oregon State’s offense has been a mess all season, but Saturday’s performance was a low point. The Beavers rushed for just 67 yards, with leading back Anthony Hankerson managing 38 on 14 carries after an early touchdown drive that consumed 7:40 and showed fleeting promise. Quarterback Maalik Murphy, who entered averaging nearly 300 passing yards per game, went a dismal 5-of-18 for 68 yards, plagued by missed targets and cautious play-calling. As Murphy himself admitted, “I’m not utilizing my skill set the best way I can… I got to be better.”
The root issue? An inability to run the ball consistently, which Bray acknowledged postgame: “When you’re struggling running the ball, it’s hard to be that offense.” The Beavers aimed for balance but ended up stagnant, unable to “take the top off the defense,” as Bray put it. With penalties derailing drives and the line failing to create holes, is this a scheme problem under offensive coordinator Ryan Gunderson, or a talent shortfall? Murphy’s timid throws suggest confidence issues, and without a reliable ground game, OSU risks becoming one-dimensional—and predictably ineffective. If they can’t fix this against a softer upcoming slate (Houston, Appalachian State, Wake Forest), bowl eligibility—requiring six wins in the remaining eight games—feels like a pipe dream.
2. Is the Defense Capable of Sustaining Effort, or Is It Smoke and Mirrors?
For a brief moment, OSU’s defense looked competent, holding Oregon to a turnover on downs early and tipping passes in the first quarter. Linebacker Shamar Meikle racked up 11 tackles, and edge rusher Takari Hickle notched a sack. But the facade crumbled: The Ducks rushed for 281 yards, with six players gaining at least 26, and Moore escaped pressure repeatedly, scrambling for 53 yards. Defensive back Sailasa Vadrawale III noted, “We’ve got to keep playing defense” regardless of circumstances, but the unit has now surrendered 156 points through four games—the worst in the country.
Bray praised the early stops but criticized miscommunications that led to big plays, like Moore’s 49-yard touchdown pass to Gary Bryant Jr. With injuries forcing mid-game adjustments— including inserting new transfer Conrad Hussey at nickel, who nearly had a pick but blew assignments on scores—the defense lacks depth and discipline. They’ve given up 34+ points in every game, exposing vulnerabilities against even middling offenses. Can coordinator Keith Heyward instill consistency, or is this unit simply outmatched in a season where OSU is essentially independent, playing a patchwork schedule? Future opponents like Washington State (twice) will test whether this is fixable or foundational.
3. Does Trent Bray Need to Shake Up His Staff—or Is the Problem Bigger?
Special teams, a perennial headache, reared its head again. While long snapping improved enough for punter AJ Winsor to set a school record with 427 yards, a critical mismatch allowed Oregon’s punter to rumble 21 yards on a fake, extending a drive that ended in a touchdown. Bray’s frustration was palpable: “Everyone’s got to be accountable for their job.” But after four games of calamities—from snapping woes to blocked kicks—questions swirl around special teams coordinator Jamie Christian. Is a midseason change viable, or does OSU lack the resources and depth for it?
Bray, in his first year as head coach, has been candid about the struggles, urging his players to “believe” in their potential after hanging with Oregon for a half. But with the program spearheading the Pac-12’s revival alongside Washington State—adding teams like Boise State and Fresno State next year—the stakes extend beyond 2025. Realignment has left OSU in limbo, and a winless start risks eroding fan support and recruiting momentum. Bray’s message of accountability must start at the top: If the Beavers continue spiraling, does athletic director Scott Barnes consider a broader overhaul? As one OregonLive.com column noted, Fans and observers have likely reached the point of quoting modern philosopher Charli XCX: “I think the apple’s rotten right to the core.”—harsh, but the listless vibe demands introspection.
4. How Do You Salvage Morale and Secure the Future?
Starting 0-4 is demoralizing, especially after a competitive 2023. Players like Murphy and Vadrawale spoke of learning experiences and moving on, but body language told another story: shoulders dropping, heads tilting skyward as the scoreboard ballooned. Bray emphasized playing “a full 60 minutes,” but sustaining energy against juggernauts like Oregon and Texas Tech (a prior 45-14 loss) has proven elusive.
With a theoretically easier schedule ahead—non-Power Four foes like Houston (3-0) and Sam Houston—OSU has a shot at wins to reach bowl eligibility. But morale ties into recruiting and retention in the NIL era. Can Bray rally this group to “match hats with hats,” as he put it, or will transfers flee a sinking ship? The Beavers’ path forward hinges on proving they’re “capable of being” competitive for four quarters, as Bray insists. Otherwise, 2025 could be remembered as the year the rebuild stalled before it began.
In the end, Oregon State’s loss to Oregon wasn’t shocking—the Ducks are playoff contenders, after all. But the manner of defeat, coupled with a winless start, raises existential questions about identity, execution, and leadership. Friday’s game against Houston is more than a matchup; it’s a referendum on whether this season can be salvaged—or if deeper changes are inevitable. For a program with a proud history, the answers can’t come soon enough.
Be the first to comment